All Buffalo nickel dates

1924-S Buffalo Nickel

Semi-key

One of the hardest Buffalo nickels in mint state. The mintage is low, the strike is usually poor, and almost none were set aside.

Obverse and reverse of a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel
Representative image of the series, not of this date or mintmark. Verify the exact date, mintmark and variety on the coin you are considering.

Mintage

Business strikes
1,437,000
Mint
San Francisco (S)
Mintage rank
4 of 64

Rank 1 is the lowest business-strike mintage in the series. Mintage is what the Mint produced, not what survives. These circulated for decades as everyday money, and on this design the date wore off before almost anything else, so a large share of what survives cannot be attributed to a year at all.

Reading the figure

Among the 22 San Francisco issues in the series it is the 4th smallest. Of the 28,315,000 struck across all mints in 1924, this issue accounts for 5%. Philadelphia struck 15 times as many that year. The 1924 split ran Philadelphia 21,620,000, Denver 5,258,000 and San Francisco 1,437,000. The series median is 9,418,000, so fewer than half as many of these were struck as a typical date.

Every sentence above is computed from the mintage table on this page, not asserted separately.

Scarcity tier

Semi-key

Assigned from reported mintage alone: under 750,000 is a key date, under 2,500,000 is a semi-key.

This is a reproducible label derived from the mintage column, not a market valuation and not a Coin Curator price opinion. The same thresholds apply to every series on this site. Several dates are far harder or far easier to obtain than their mintage implies; where that is true, it is stated above.

Recent sold prices

Last checked Sep 16, 2026 · most recent sale Sep 13, 2026

What certified 1924-S Buffalo nickels actually sold for on eBay in the last 90 days, grouped by grade band. Every figure below is a completed sale of a PCGS, NGC or ANACS coin in a straight grade. This is a record of what changed hands, not a price guide, an appraisal, or a prediction of what yours is worth.

Good to Fine

PO1 to F15

$115

Median of 8 sales

Lowest
$30
Highest
$275
The 4 most recent sales

Seller titles, verbatim. An ended eBay listing stays readable for about 90 days, so older links will expire.

Very Fine to XF

VF20 to XF45

$795

Median of 3 sales

Lowest
$239
Highest
$840
The 3 most recent sales

Seller titles, verbatim. An ended eBay listing stays readable for about 90 days, so older links will expire.

How to read these

  • The median is the middle sale after removing outliers. The range is every sale kept, including the outliers, so you can see how wide the market actually is.
  • Grade drives most of the difference. A band with three sales tells you far less than a band with thirty, and the count is shown so you can weigh it.
  • Sales of coins in “Details”, “Genuine” or cleaned holders are excluded, as are proofs, replicas, lots, and mounted coins. Those sell at prices that would not describe the coin on this page.
  • So is any sale priced below what this same date fetches in a lower grade, which is impossible for a real coin and is how a counterfeit in a convincing holder gives itself away.
  • 1 further qualifying sale fell in a grade band with fewer than 3 sales, which is too few to report a median from, so it is not shown.

Coin Curator does not grade, authenticate, or appraise coins, and holds no licensed price guide or population data. How this data is collected.

The date wears off first. Fraser placed the date on a raised shoulder of the obverse, where it took the full force of circulation. Read the full note on the series page.

What to check before buying

Specific to the 1924-S:

  1. 1The date sits on a raised shoulder that wore away faster than anything else on the coin, so dateless Buffalo nickels are extremely common. Confirm the date is genuinely struck and readable rather than restored with acid, which leaves a pitted, dull patch around the digits.

And for any certified coin

Verify the certification number on the grading service’s own lookup rather than from a photograph of the label, match the listing images to the certification record including grade and any variety attribution, look for cleaning, compare the mintmark against published photographs of the genuine issue, and read the return policy before buying. The grading guide covers each of these in full.

Coin Curator does not grade, authenticate, or appraise coins, and holds no licensed price guide or population data. Where this page shows recent sold prices, they are records of completed eBay sales, not a valuation of any particular coin. These are verification steps, not an appraisal.

Verify a certification number

Look a 1924-S certification number up on the service’s own site. A photograph of a label proves nothing.

PCGS cert lookup NGC cert lookup ANACS cert lookup

Each service publishes its own guarantee with conditions and exclusions. Compare PCGS, NGC and ANACS.

Find a 1924-S for sale

Opens an eBay search for this exact date and mint. Coin Curator does not list inventory, hold stock, or set prices; verify each listing, seller, and return policy directly.

Affiliate link: Coin Curator may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosure.

Search eBay for 1924-S

Common questions

How many 1924-S Buffalo nickels were minted?

The San Francisco Mint struck 1,437,000 1924-S Buffalo nickels for circulation. That is the 4th lowest business-strike mintage of the 64 date and mintmark combinations in the series.

Is the 1924-S Buffalo nickel a key date?

Coin Curator labels it a semi-key, assigned from reported mintage alone: under 750,000 struck is a key date and under 2,500,000 is a semi-key. The same thresholds are used for every series on this site, so the tiers are comparable between them. That label describes production, not market value or how hard the coin is to find today. One of the hardest Buffalo nickels in mint state. The mintage is low, the strike is usually poor, and almost none were set aside.

What should I check before buying a 1924-S Buffalo nickel?

Verify the certification number on the grading service's own lookup page, match the listing photographs to the certification record, check for cleaning, and compare the mintmark shape and position against published photographs of the genuine issue. The date sits on a raised shoulder that wore away faster than anything else on the coin, so dateless Buffalo nickels are extremely common. Confirm the date is genuinely struck and readable rather than restored with acid, which leaves a pitted, dull patch around the digits.

Related dates

1924-P21,620,0001924-D5,258,0001923-S6,142,0001925-S6,256,0001926-S970,0001921-S1,557,000

Guides for this coin

All guides →
Vintage Guide

Buffalo Nickel Key Dates & Varieties

1913-1938. James Earle Fraser design. Half a dozen famous key dates, two iconic die varieties (Three-Legged Buffalo, Two-Feathers), and one of the most beloved aesthetics in US coinage.

2 min readEducation

Error Coins: Types, Attribution, and Verification

Learn the difference between off-center strikes, doubled dies, mules, broadstrikes, and post-mint damage, plus the records to check before buying.

1 min readBuying Guide

How to Spot a Counterfeit or Doctored Coin

Use weight, dimensions, surfaces, mintmark details, holder inspection, and certification records as screening checks. Learn the warning signs of altered coins and fake slabs.

1 min readBuying Guide

MS-63 vs MS-65 vs MS-67: Which Grade to Actually Buy

Adjacent grades can carry very different market evidence. Learn how to compare surfaces, eye appeal, population data, and current records before choosing a grade.

1 min read

Mintage sources

Mintage figures are U.S. Mint production records, cross-checked against the published tables below on 2026-08-01. Where those tables disagree, the disagreement is disclosed on the affected page rather than resolved silently.

Spotted an error? Submit a correction.